Why Do I Feel Guilty Setting Boundaries?

spending time alone before setting boundaries which can cause guilt

Taking time alone helps you reconnect with what you actually need before you set a boundary.

“Boundaries” is a word that often gets weaponized when people use therapy speak. It gets used as an excuse to not be uncomfortable or to do what is most convenient. These false boundaries are what give the word “boundaries” a really bad wrap.

Boundaries are extremely important. They actually allow us to be in relationships instead of preventing us from feeling connection with others. But sometimes, boundaries can make you feel guilty.

What Boundaries Are Not

  • Ways to cut people out of your life.

  • Telling somebody what they can or cannot do.

  • Meant to silo you away from your community.

  • Always necessary to say out loud.

What Boundaries Are

  • What you will say and do.

  • Meant to protect relationships.

  • Should help you maintain energy.

  • A response to harm or potential harm.

  • At times, internal deals that you make with yourself.

Now that we have that established, let’s talk about why people who have a history of trauma and/or people pleasing find boundaries really hard to set. Are you this person? Does the thought of setting a boundary with anyone induce sweating, high heart rate, feeling ill, or fear of rejection? Let’s talk about it.

Why People-Pleasing Develops as a Trauma Response

What Is the Fawn Response?

Have you ever heard of the “fawning” response? (If not, I have a whole blog post on it here). The fawn response is the nervous system threat response that has somebody appeasing and submitting rather than fighting or fleeing. This is done for many reasons, but usually happens when a person has a history of being overpowered or a perceived threat of being overpowered.

Many people who have experienced domestic violence, for example, would find themselves fawning. They know it isn’t safe to fight or run away because their abuser could get even more angry. Therefore, making the other person happy with you is the best way to go.

Over time, the fawn response can become a habit. It often isn’t something somebody does by choice, but is more like muscle memory than anything else. Setting boundaries is in direct conflict with people-pleasing because boundary setting has the possibility of making the other person upset.

Why Saying No Triggers Guilt and Anxiety

Saying “no” can mean dealing with your own anxiety and/or guilt.

It is not a surprise that many people have a really hard time being with their feelings. I work all of the time with people who have somatic manifestations of their emotions because they have learned, over time, to ignore them. Many people have this idea that feelings will completely overwhelm and derail them.

What Is Distress Tolerance?

This is why distress tolerance is a big part of being able to set boundaries and say “no.” Oftentimes, people would rather be inconvenienced, stressed out, and do unnecessary emotional or physical labor to avoid feeling this discomfort.

However, imagine if you were able to tolerate the discomfort of saying “no” - a whole new world of possibilities would be open to you!

Tips for Building Your Tolerance for Discomfort

Here are some tips for working on expanding your tolerance for feeling uncomfortable:

  • Do a hard workout. Notice thoughts that come up when things get really challenging.

  • Journal about something that you have been emotionally ignoring.

  • Meditate. Notice what comes up. Can you be with it without judgement?

How to Enforce a Boundary Without Fear

The Broken Record Technique

First of all, I really do believe that a lot of this is about the distress tolerance of continuing to say no and witnessing how that impacts somebody. Have you ever heard the saying that “the people who are most likely to take advantage of you are the ones who will be the most upset about your boundaries?” Well, it isn’t a saying for nothing.

Here is where I will lean on the wisdom of Dr. Marsha Linehan (rest in peace, queen), the creator of Dialectical Behavior Therapy. She proposes that we use the “broken record statement,” or the reiteration of the boundary in a way that is accessible to us and rehearsed by us. This means, if you have already had a conversation with somebody about your boundary, you can continue to use the same phrase or response every time the other person questions it. It takes the guess work out of reinforcing your own self-protection.

How can somatic therapy help you to set boundaries?

By being able to listen to the body through somatic therapy and what it is saying, we can understand a bit more about what you need and want in any given situation. This doesn’t mean that we set boundaries always based on one feeling or hunch, but it helps us to honor where your feeling state is with any given situation.

Using Role-Play and Experiential Exercises

Somatic therapy uses the nervous system and the felt sense in the body to be able to help people to expand their capacity to tolerate discomfort. This allows people to be able to do the hard work of protecting themselves while also not feeling completely dysregulated by it.

In somatic therapy, we also do many experiential exercises. This includes things such as role playing, where the client would be able to feel in their bodies a taste of how it would be to set a boundary with somebody before they have to do it. The somatic therapist, in this case, would be able to help the person familiarize themselves with the level of activation that they are feeling at the time so that it doesn’t surprise and/or overwhelm them in the moment.

Are you or somebody you know trying to create healthier dynamics in their relationships? Are you seeking somatic therapy in Kansas City? We are here to help! Contact us here.

Don't do it alone. Explore Somatic Therapy In Kansas City

Setting and holding boundaries is worth every ounce of discomfort it brings. Whether it be Cognitive Behavioral Therapy, Somatic Experiencing, or any mindfulness intervention, therapy is an essential tool for learning to set boundaries with more ease.

Don't hesitate to reach out to one of our fabulous therapists in Kansas City today! Lauren and Kathryn are currently taking new clients.

 

Frequently Asked Questions About Setting Boundaries

 

Stevie Olson-Spiegel is a Licensed Therapist and Somatic Experiencing Practitioner located in Kansas City. She uses Somatic Experiencing as her main body-based trauma healing modality, as well as EMDR. As an Intuitive Eating Counselor, she uses these principles to help her clients challenge their relationship with their cultural misconceptions about their body and food.


More Blog Posts

View All >

Next
Next

Taking Care of Your Mind and Body During the Holidays